The Evidence for the Top Quark: Objectivity and Bias in Collaborative Experimentation

The Evidence for the Top Quark offers both a historical and philosophical perspective on an important recent discovery in particle physics: the first evidence for the elementary particle known as the top quark. Drawing on published reports, oral histories, and internal documents from the large collaboration that performed the experiment, Kent Staley explores in detail the controversies and politics that surrounded this major scientific result. At the same time the book seeks to defend an objective theory of scientific evidence based on error probabilities. Such a theory provides an illuminating explication of the points of contention in the debate over the evidence for the top quark. Philosophers wishing to defend the objectivity of the results of scientific research must face unflinchingly the realities of scientific practice, and this book attempts to do precisely that.

• Unique behind-the-scenes perspective on a major scientific discovery • Important defense of the objectivity of scientific evidence • Integration of history and philosophy will make the book appeal equally to both historians and philosophers of science